COMEX Silver Gives Back Its Build While Registered Stock Keeps Rising

COMEX Silver Gives Back Its Build While Registered Stock Keeps Rising
  • Written by
  • Huan Koh
  • Published on
  • Oct 12, 2026
  • Copy link
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

COMEX Silver Gives Back Its Build While Registered Stock Keeps Rising

Last week this column revised its framing to acknowledge that COMEX silver had stopped bleeding and was refilling, on the strength of two consecutive weekly builds totalling seven million ounces. The reversal lasted exactly one week. COMEX silver stocks fell 4.51 million ounces to 333.07 million by 7 October, and InProved recorded the week’s outflow at 5.1 million ounces, describing it as more than enough to erase the prior week’s build. The 9 October print alone took 2.48 million ounces out, the second heavy outflow in a row and the largest single session since April, with JP Morgan accounting for 1.31 million of it and 4.5 million across three days. That is 88% of the entire weekly outflow from one depository, which fits precisely with the concentration this column documented last week. What makes the week genuinely interesting rather than merely volatile is that registered stock went up while all of this was happening.

Five Million Ounces Leave in a Week and Registered Still Gains

The warehouse dashboard dated 7 October shows a combined total of 333.07 million ounces split 102.22 million registered against 230.85 million eligible, which works out to 30.69% and 69.31% respectively. Set that against last week’s 337.58 million, split 101.10 and 236.48, and the decomposition is clean: registered rose 1.12 million ounces while eligible fell 5.63 million, and those two numbers sum to the 4.51 million decline in the total. Every ounce that left the exchange came out of the eligible category, and the deliverable pool grew through the outflow. Over three months the divergence is starker still, with total stock up 6.83 million ounces or 2.1% while registered is up 8.71 million or 9.3% and eligible is down 1.88 million or 0.8%. Registered silver now stands at 20,444 contracts at the five-thousand-ounce contract size, against roughly 18,700 three months ago. The metal leaving COMEX is the metal that was never committed to delivery in the first place.

This matters because it inverts the squeeze narrative that usually accompanies a five-million-ounce weekly outflow. A genuine scramble for deliverable metal drains registered stock, because that is the category futures holders can actually stand for delivery against. What is happening here is the opposite: registered is being built while eligible is withdrawn. The dashboard’s own annotation adds the piece that explains most of it, noting that eligible includes 70.17 million ounces of iShares Silver Trust inventory, or 30.4% of the category, leaving 160.68 million ounces of genuinely unencumbered eligible metal. A holder of eligible silver who wants it elsewhere faces no obstacle to moving it, and a depository that wants to upgrade metal to registered status files paperwork. Both have been happening simultaneously. The honest reading is that COMEX is becoming a smaller but more deliverable warehouse, and anyone treating the headline decline as evidence of imminent delivery failure has the sign wrong on the only category that matters for delivery.

Every Physical Premium in the Complex Is Pointing the Same Way

Three separate premium gauges published this week all read the same direction, which is rare enough to be worth setting out together. The China Premium Monitor dated 9 October puts Shanghai silver at a 12.98% premium to LBMA, with SGE at $68.05 against London at $60.23, a spread of $7.82 an ounce. The five-day average sits at 12.79% and the thirty-day range runs 12.02% to 13.10%, so the current print sits near the top of a band that has itself been climbing since early July. The three-month trend panel shows the premium starting the window around 11.5%, spending August oscillating between 12% and 12.8%, and establishing a higher floor through September. This is not a spike. It is a level that has been ratcheting upward for a quarter and shows no sign of mean-reverting, and it exists in the same venue where gold commands 0.26%.

India tells the same story from the opposite side of the world. The India Premium Monitor dated 8 October shows IBJA silver at a 3.26% premium to duty-paid parity, with the IBJA fix at $69.77 against parity at $67.57, a spread of $2.20 an ounce. That is the top of its own thirty-day range of minus 1.58% to plus 3.26%, and the five-day average at 2.34% confirms the move is recent and still building. InProved noted the premium is at its highest in thirty days, up from minus 1.6% in late August, and attributed it to Indian buyers paying up ahead of Diwali. The three-month panel makes the recovery visible: the series ran at 6% to 8% in early July, collapsed through August into outright discount with a trough near minus 2%, and has climbed steadily since mid-September. A market that was dumping silver below import parity eight weeks ago is now paying three percent above it. Set the Indian and Chinese gauges beside the vault data in the companion gold analysis, where Indian deliverable silver held firm at 231.66 tonnes while gold discharged, and the picture is consistent across three independent measurements: physical silver is being bid in Asia and held rather than turned over.

The December Basis Widens for the First Time Since August

Silver’s forward curve did the same thing gold’s did on the same day and for the same reason, which is useful because it isolates what is common from what is specific. The 9 October dashboard shows spot at $61.050, up $1.855 or 3.13% on the session, with the structure marked contango. The December spread prints 27.8 cents against 23.5 the prior session, a gain of 4.3 cents or 18.3%, and March, May and July widened by 6.8, 7.0 and 8.0 cents respectively to $1.03, $1.56 and $2.08. InProved’s note said the spreads widened across the curve, outpacing time decay, with futures running slightly ahead of spot and carry building back in on a strong up day, the same pattern as gold. Week-on-week the direction is still down, with December off 19.0% from last week’s 34.3 cents, and the basis history panel shows a decline from roughly 92 cents in mid-August to the current level, a fall of 69.8% over seven weeks. The front of the curve remains the steepest segment, with December to March costing 75.2 cents against 53 and 52 cents for the two later steps.

Reading the two metals together is what makes the day’s move interpretable. Both curves widened on the same session, both after the same move higher in spot, and both were described by the publisher in near-identical language. That strongly suggests a common driver, which on a day when gold rose 1.26% and silver 3.13% is most plausibly a repricing of financing conditions rather than anything metal-specific. What remains after subtracting the common component is silver’s front-end steepness, which has persisted for a month while the rest of its curve flattened, and which is directionally consistent with the Asian premium data though far weaker than it. The difference in magnitude is the thing to keep in proportion. A 27.8-cent December spread on a $61 metal is 0.46% of spot; a 12.98% Shanghai premium is twenty-eight times that. If physical tightness were transmitting cleanly into the Western paper curve, the December basis would not be in orderly contango at all. The gap between those two measurements has been the defining feature of silver for two months, and nothing this week narrowed it.

Shanghai's Pool Stops Shrinking as Spot Metal Moves Into Futures

The China Vault Monitor dated 9 October puts combined SGE and SHFE silver holdings at 2,360.1 tonnes, or 75.88 million ounces, down 7.9 tonnes or 0.33% on the day, with a weekly net change of minus 8.4 tonnes. The split is 877.6 tonnes at SGE and 1,482.5 at SHFE, and the two sum exactly to the combined figure. What the daily move conceals is a rotation that has been running for three weeks. Against the 21 September reading this column cited two weeks ago, SGE is up 23.8 tonnes and SHFE is up 59.2, for a combined gain of 83.0 tonnes, and the SGE leg carries a plus 2.79% weekly change stamp against SHFE’s minus 0.53% daily. Metal has been moving into the Chinese system as a whole and disproportionately into the futures warehouse rather than the spot exchange. The three-year panel places the current level in context: the window runs from a period high of 2,955.3 tonnes to a low of 602.4, the period change is minus 505.1 tonnes, and today’s 2,360.1 sits 20.1% below the high and 291.8% above the low.

Put the Chinese vault data beside the Chinese premium data and a tension emerges that is worth naming rather than smoothing over. Shanghai is paying a 12.98% premium to London, which says metal is scarce there. Shanghai’s vaults have gained 83 tonnes in three weeks, which says metal is arriving. Those are compatible only if the arriving metal is being absorbed as fast as it lands, which is what a sustained premium with rising inventory actually describes: demand running ahead of a supply response that is itself accelerating. The alternative reading, that the premium is a currency or regulatory artifact rather than a physical one, cannot be dismissed from this data alone, and the withdrawal of India’s import tax benefit this week is a reminder that policy can move these spreads without any change in underlying demand. What would distinguish them is the premium’s behaviour as the inventory build continues. A genuine physical premium should compress as metal arrives; one that holds at thirteen percent through an 83-tonne build is telling you the demand is larger than the flow. Three more weekly prints will settle it, and that is the specific thing to watch between now and the end of the month.

What the Data Means for Dealers, Investors, and Traders

For bullion dealers, the registered-versus-eligible split should change how this week’s headline is read. COMEX lost 5.1 million ounces on the week and 2.48 million in a single session, the largest since April, but registered stock rose 1.12 million ounces to 102.22 million and is up 9.3% over three months. Deliverable availability improved while total stock fell, and 70.17 million ounces of the eligible category is iShares inventory that was never available anyway. Sourcing against COMEX is therefore easier this week, not harder, despite the alarming top-line number. The Asian picture is the opposite and dealers serving those markets should plan accordingly: Shanghai is paying a 12.98% premium and India 3.26% over duty-paid parity, both near the top of their thirty-day ranges, and Indian deliverable silver held firm at 231.66 tonnes through a festival week in which gold discharged 17.9%. Metal moving east is being kept rather than turned over.

For conservative investors, the central tension is now explicit enough to state plainly. Three independent physical gauges — Shanghai at 12.98%, India at 3.26% and Indian vault stocks holding firm — all say silver is bid in Asia. The Western paper curve says the opposite, with the December basis in orderly contango at 27.8 cents, which is 0.46% of spot against a Shanghai premium twenty-eight times that size. Those two measurements have been diverging for two months and nothing this week narrowed the gap. An investor should size the position according to which market they believe sets the price, and should be honest that the Western curve has been the better predictor over the past quarter while the Asian premiums have been the better description of physical reality. A reasonable base case puts support at $58, resistance at $64 and then $67, and a twelve-month range of $80 to $88 if the gold-silver ratio compresses from 69.13 toward 57 while gold reaches the band set out in the companion analysis.

For active traders, the specific thing to watch is the Chinese premium’s response to the Chinese inventory build. SGE and SHFE vaults have added 83.0 tonnes over three weeks to 2,360.1 and the premium has held near 13%, which is only consistent if demand is outrunning an accelerating supply response. A genuine physical premium compresses as metal arrives; one that holds through an 83-tonne build is a stronger signal than the premium level itself. Three more weekly prints settle it. On the curve, the 9 October session saw December widen 4.3 cents to 27.8 and the deferred legs widen 6.8, 7.0 and 8.0 cents, the first broad re-widening since August, which matters more as a change of direction than as a level. The front-end steepness remains the one silver-specific feature, with December to March at 75.2 cents against 53 and 52 cents for the later steps. A close above $64 with the Shanghai premium still above 12% would be the first time both markets agreed in two months and would justify adding; below $58 the physical thesis is not wrong but it is early enough to be unfundable.

Want to know more?

Talk to your consultants to pick their brains about Gold Prices.

Learn More

InProved makes it easy to procure and hold gold and silver bullion products in a tax-efficient manner. Ready to explore?

Most Recent Posts

  • All Post
  • Blog
  • Fund Management
  • In Depth Analytics
  • Topics
  • Uncategorized
    •   Back
    • Tax Benefits
    • Company Details
    • Gold
    • Directors
    • Beneficiaries
    • Financial Accounts
    • Digital Services
    • Promotions

Category

Tags

Hugo Pascal’s observation about the AU9999 contract hitting a 10-week volume high underscores the increasing significance of physical gold trading on the Shanghai Gold Exchange. This trend not only highlights robust domestic demand in China but also reflects broader shifts in the global gold market toward physical-backed assets.

  • Most Recent Posts

Latest articles

Tool and strategies modern teams need to help their companies grow.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Invite users to stay updated with exclusive insights and market trends by subscribing to the newsletter.

Important Disclosure Information

InProved Pte. Ltd. (“InProved”, UEN 201602269C). InProved is regulated by the Ministry of Law (“Minlaw”) and holds a Precious Stones and Precious Metals license for dealing in bullion products (PSPM License PS20190001819). For additional legal and privacy related information related to InProved, please visit are terms and conditions.

Our products and services are only available to Accredited Investors. Investing in bullion involves risk, and there is always the potential of losing money. Certain bullion products are not suitable for all investors. The rate of return on investments can vary widely over time, especially for long-term investments. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Before investing, consider your investment objectives and any fees and expenses that may be charged by InProved and any third-party stakeholders. The content provided herein is for informational purposes only and is not investment or financial advice, tax or legal advice, an offer, solicitation of an offer, or advice to buy or sell or hold bullion products. This material has not been reviewed by the Minlaw.

Statements made are not facts, including statements regarding trends, market conditions and the experience or expertise of the author or quoted individual(s) are based on current expectations, estimates, opinions and/or beliefs. Opinions expressed by other members on InProved should not be viewed as investment recommendations from InProved. Endorsements were provided at the request of InProved. InProved is not affiliated with and does not purport to own or control any third-party content linked herein.

Copyright © 2026 InProved Pte Ltd (UEN 201616594C, PSPM license PS20190001819)