Gold’s Quiet Divergence: Weak Chinese Withdrawals, Rising Futures Participation, and Premiums Refusing to Break
Copy link
Gold markets are currently showing an unusual divergence between physical withdrawal activity and futures participation. On one side, physical demand indicators in China remain subdued, with Shanghai Gold Exchange (SGE) withdrawals recording their weakest start to a year since the 2020 pandemic lockdowns. On the other side, futures participation on the Shanghai Futures Exchange (SHFE) has begun rebuilding, while regional premiums continue holding above LBMA benchmarks.
LBMA vault holdings for April 2026 increased modestly to 9,372 metric tons, representing a 0.35% month-on-month increase. In China, gold continues trading at approximately $4,723–$4,750 per ounce, maintaining a premium of roughly 0.3% over LBMA pricing.
Meanwhile, SHFE gold open interest surged 5.7% week-on-week to 316,611 contracts, reaching a six-week high. This increase in futures participation stands in contrast to weakening physical withdrawal data. Monthly SGE withdrawals totaled just 102.7 tons, approximately 25% below the eight-year average and 23% lower than the previous month. Cumulative withdrawals for the first four months of 2026 reached only 448.1 tons, marking the weakest start to a year since the pandemic disruptions of 2020.
At the same time, options markets show that bearish positioning is beginning to soften. GLD options continue to show puts trading at a premium to calls, but downside protection demand has been cooling, reflected in softer one-month and three-month 25-delta risk reversals.
These figures describe a gold market where physical buying has slowed materially, but futures participation and regional pricing resilience indicate that broader investor interest has not disappeared.
LBMA Vault Holdings Edge Higher
LBMA gold holdings increased modestly during April 2026, rising to approximately 9,372 metric tons. The increase of 0.35% month-on-month reflects a gradual accumulation of metal within London vault systems.
Unlike silver, where inventories have shown greater volatility, gold holdings in LBMA vaults have remained comparatively stable. The increase indicates that physical gold continues flowing into major storage systems even as demand conditions vary across regions.
London remains the dominant global hub for institutional gold storage, meaning changes in LBMA inventory levels continue to influence broader market liquidity and settlement conditions.
Gold in China continues trading above LBMA benchmarks despite slowing withdrawal activity. Recent pricing shows gold trading around $4,723.3 to $4,749.9 per ounce, maintaining premiums of approximately 0.3% to 0.32% over London pricing.
The Shanghai Gold Benchmark (SHAUPM) recently closed at approximately $4,749.88 per ounce versus an LBMA reference price near $4,734.65.
The persistence of premiums is notable because it contrasts with the weakness observed in physical withdrawal volumes. Even as fewer tons are leaving the SGE vault system, domestic prices have not fallen into discount territory relative to international markets
This indicates that while outright physical demand has slowed, the domestic market has not entered a phase of oversupply.
The clearest sign of slowing physical demand comes from Shanghai Gold Exchange withdrawal data.
Monthly withdrawals for April totaled approximately 102.7 metric tons, representing a 25% decline relative to the eight-year seasonal average and a 23% decline from the previous month.
More significantly, cumulative withdrawals for the first four months of 2026 reached only 448.1 tons. According to the dataset, this represents the weakest January-to-April period since the 2020 pandemic lockdowns.
SGE withdrawals are widely used as a proxy for physical gold demand in China because they measure the quantity of metal leaving exchange vaults for fabrication, wholesale distribution, or private ownership.
The weakness in withdrawals therefore suggests that Chinese physical demand has softened materially relative to previous years.
While physical withdrawals have weakened, futures participation has moved in the opposite direction.
Open interest on the Shanghai Futures Exchange increased by 5.7% week-on-week to 316,611 contracts, reaching a six-week high.
The increase indicates that traders are returning to the futures market despite slower physical demand. Rising open interest generally reflects the addition of new positions rather than the closure of existing ones.
This divergence between physical withdrawals and futures participation suggests that market participants are increasingly expressing views through leveraged or hedging instruments rather than direct physical accumulation.
Options positioning also reflects a moderation in bearish sentiment.
GLD options continue to show a mild bearish bias, with puts maintaining a premium over calls. However, the demand for downside protection has begun cooling.
This shift is visible in the softening of one-month and three-month 25-delta risk reversals. Risk reversals measure the relative pricing of upside versus downside options, providing insight into directional demand within the options market.
The decline in downside premium indicates that investors are becoming less aggressive in hedging against further price declines.
The interaction between weakening physical withdrawals and stable regional premiums provides an important view of current market structure.
Physical demand indicators in China are clearly softer than earlier in the cycle, yet pricing has remained resilient relative to international benchmarks. At the same time, futures participation has increased and downside hedging pressure has eased.
This combination suggests that the market is transitioning away from panic-driven positioning and toward a more balanced phase where speculative and institutional activity is beginning to stabilize.
For bullion dealers, the most important development is the divergence between physical withdrawals and pricing resilience. SGE withdrawals have fallen to their weakest start since 2020, yet Shanghai premiums remain positive and stable. This suggests that while end-user demand has softened, the market has not yet shifted into outright surplus conditions.
For conservative investors, the decline in physical withdrawal activity may indicate slower momentum in retail and wholesale demand, particularly within China. However, stable premiums, rising futures participation, and easing downside hedging pressure suggest that broader market confidence has not collapsed. The current environment appears more consistent with consolidation than structural weakness.
For traders, the current setup points toward a market attempting to stabilize after earlier volatility. In the near term, the combination of weak withdrawal data and rebuilding open interest suggests that gold may continue consolidating within a broad range around the $4,600 to $4,900 per ounce area. The resilience of Shanghai premiums near 0.3% indicates that downside follow-through may remain limited unless physical demand deteriorates further.
Over the longer term, the picture remains constructive, though less explosive than earlier in the year. If Chinese physical withdrawals begin recovering while futures participation continues increasing from current levels, the market would likely regain momentum toward the $5,000 per ounce threshold. Conversely, if withdrawals remain near pandemic-era lows and open interest growth stalls, gold may spend longer trading sideways while waiting for a stronger macro catalyst.
Across vault inventories, withdrawal activity, futures participation, and options positioning, the figures describe a gold market that has cooled materially on the physical side while retaining enough structural support to prevent a deeper breakdown in price.
Hugo Pascal’s observation about the AU9999 contract hitting a 10-week volume high underscores the increasing significance of physical gold trading on the Shanghai Gold Exchange. This trend not only highlights robust domestic demand in China but also reflects broader shifts in the global gold market toward physical-backed assets.
Latest articles
Tool and strategies modern teams need to help their companies grow.
Invite users to stay updated with exclusive insights and market trends by subscribing to the newsletter.
Start stacking your bullion. Download the InProved app and build your legacy in gold and silver.
+65 8899 3720
support@inproved.com